اجعلنا صفحة البداية RSS خدمة Add to favorite Facebook Twitter

Advanced

Rights groups: Israeli ambulance rules discriminate
Published Thursday 19/11/2009 (updated) 07/01/2010 17:02
Font- Font+
An Israeli MDA ambulance [MaanImages - Archive]
Bethlehem – Ma’an – Human rights groups are calling on the Israeli government to cancel instructions preventing ambulances from entering Palestinian neighborhoods in East Jerusalem without a police escort.

According to Adalah, The Legal Center for Arab Minority Rights in Israel, Magen David Adom (MDA) ambulances “must wait in a Jewish neighborhood adjacent to the Palestinian neighborhood and may not enter it to transfer the injured or the sick person to the hospital until a police escort arrives, even in life threatening situations.”

In many cases, patients face long delays in receiving treatment, and must be transferred by their own family’s cars, risking complications or increased severity of illness, the rights advocates say.

In a news release on Thursday, Adalah said the procedures “violate the first rule in the work of emergency crews, which is to provide medical aid as soon as possible, and the state's obligation to ensure the life and physical well-being of each person under its authority.”

Further, the rules may amount to a violation of medical ethics and “may constitute cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment under international law,” the group added in a statement.

The Israeli Ministry of Health did not immediately return calls from Ma’an seeking comment.

Adalah, along with Physicians for Human Rights and the Al-Mezan Centre for Human rights sent an urgent letter to the Israeli Deputy Minister of Health and the Jerusalem Police Chief on 10 November demanding the cancellation of the guidelines.

Haneen Naamneh, the attorney working on the case for Adalah, said that the organization had not yet received a response to its letter, and is considering filing a legal petition over the matter.

The situation for Palestinians in Jerusalem is particularly dire, Naamneh said, because “There is no alternative.” The Palestine Red Crescent Society has only five ambulances in East Jerusalem, Naamneh said, which are often much farther away from Palestinian neighborhoods than their MDA counterparts.

The rights group noted that the instructions do not apply to Jewish settlements in the heart of Palestinian neighborhoods of occupied East Jerusalem. MDA ambulances travel through Palestinian areas to reach settlements without any accompaniment, the group said.

Adalah gave the example of the settlement of Nof Tzion, located in the center of the Jabal Al-Mukaber neighborhood in southeast Jerusalem. Under the government instructions, MDA ambulances travel on the same road to reach the settlement as they would to reach Palestinians in the area, but are banned from evacuating Palestinians without are police escort.

Fuad Abu Hamed, the manager of the Clalit health clinic in the East Jerusalem town of Sur Bahir was quoted in the new release saying that ambulances are sometimes forced to wait more than our on the edge of the community. In one case, an ambulance sent to evacuate a person suffering an angina waited for more than two hours at the entrance of the town. Police claimed a violent fight prevented them from entering the area.

The instructions, however, are in effect even in times of calm. “When the MDA and police implement these procedures when dealing with emergency procedures, it’s all the more unreasonable,” Naamneh said.

Naamneh also said that since East Jerusalem is occupied territory, Israel also has specific obligations under international law. “We can’t forget that East Jerusalem is occupied. It’s not like giving services to residents of Tel Aviv. Israel has extra duties as the occupier to provide services to those under its control,” since Palestinians in Jerusalem are not Israeli citizens nor residents of Israel, the attorney said.

Rights advocates also say that police escorting ambulances violates patients’ privacy rights.

Reut Katz of Physicians for Human Rights-Israel said in the news release, "The police escort of ambulances to transport patients coupled with their presence alongside medical staff during the treatment process also constitutes a flagrant violation of the privacy rights and medical confidentiality of the patient."
Print
1 ) Julie / USA
20/11/2009 00:05
Just one more documentation of Israel's criminal violation of international law & human rights..the list is infinite. What's Israel defending? Defense isn't needed here! Israel is the perpetrator blaming the victim..this is classic abuse, classic! Israel violates any rule/law/ethic/resolution known.

2 ) Inbal / Israel
22/11/2009 19:44
Wow, Julie... That's really helpful. Let's tear apart the entire administration and then everyone could be safe, right? Some Jews might get killed in the process, but that's just small details, and if any Arabs get killed in retaliation, more Jews would get killed, and then some more Arabs... Wait - weren't we here before?... This report is immensely worrying. The key paragraph is this: "The rights group noted that the instructions do not apply to Jewish settlements in the heart of Palestinian neighborhoods of occupied East Jerusalem. MDA ambulances travel through Palestinian areas to reach settlements without any accompaniment, the group said." It's unclear how MDA officials dare claim that their motive is defence, and then drive through the same supposedly dangerous routes when Jewish lives are at stake. I'm curious as to Naamneh's observation about medical rights under occupation, which probably concern situations where a legitimate reason to withhold civilian entry in lack of emergency is present; I don't see what they stand to gain with it. Tel-Aviv residents (or West Jerusalem residents) get the best medical care available, and that's exactly what East Jerusalem residents (whether one would like to consider them Israeli or not) should receive, with no exception.

3 ) Julie / USA
23/11/2009 07:39
Ok, let's! Your 'key paragraph' clearly shows discrimination against Pals who wait for ambulances..the instructions dont apply to Jews. All settler Jews are getting the best medical care, including rapid transit to hospitals. Pals do not get rapid transit, they wait. Read the example in Nof Tzion.

4 ) Julie / USA
23/11/2009 08:00
The whole article is about PALS not being evacuated fast enough. The routes are not dangerous! Ambulances freely travel their own routes which Pals are not allowed on to begin with (another discriminatory act). Your comment is hurtful to Pals, and again you blame them! Classic abuse! Psychol. 101!

5 ) Inbal / Israel
23/11/2009 17:21
Yes, Julie, thank you for explaining the whole point of the article; if you'll read my comment, you'll see that I'm not trying to deny the existence of discrimination or the fact that the above descriptions are appalling examples of it. There wasn't any part of my comment that blamed Palestinians in any way, shape or form. You'll have to excuse me for saying this, but the only psycho vibes here are coming from you.

6 ) Inbal / Israel
23/11/2009 17:24
I have to add in your defence that the merging of paragraphs in the published comment makes thing a little less clear. My comment consisted of 3 paragraphs with very different tones.
Name Country
Comment
Characters
Note: Comments will be reviewed for appropriate content. Click here for more details.

Share/Bookmark

Son: Israel shells house of Hamas political leader Haniyeh
Israeli shelling on Jabaliya kills 5, injures 40
Israeli shelling on Khan Younis kills 5

Close Next Previous
All Rights Reserved © Ma'an News Agency 2005 - 2014