اجعلنا صفحة البداية RSS خدمة Add to favorite Facebook Twitter

Advanced

Israeli settler shot dead, 4 injured in Nablus
Published Sunday 24/04/2011 (updated) 25/04/2011 21:33
Joseph`s Tomb, in the town of Balata south of Nablus [MaanImages/Rami Swidan]
NABLUS (Ma’an) -- An Israeli settler was shot dead and four others were injured early Sunday after a group of Jewish worshippers snuck into Nablus without coordinating with Palestinian or Israeli security, officials said.

Settler sources named the man killed in the incident as Jerusalem resident Ben-Yosef Livnat, a 24-year-old father of four who is the nephew of hawkish culture minister Limor Livnat, and was born in the Nablus-area settlement Elon Moreh.

Nablus governor Jibrin Al-Bakri gave an account of the incident following a police investigation, saying that at 5:45 a.m., five cars carrynig 30 settlers from Jerusalem entered Joseph's Tomb, then split off into two groups.

"They threw stones and carried out provocative acts against Palestinians," A-Bakri told Ma'an.

When police were made aware of the incidents, officers were deployed to the area and set up a checkpoint near the road, firing into the air in an attempt to disperse the group of settlers, he said.

Israeli security officials speaking on condition of anonymity told AFP that an initial investigation showed the men had tried to bypass a Palestinian patrol in a parked jeep, prompting the police to fire first in the air and then open fire on their vehicles.

When the shots were fired, Al-Bakri continued, settlers returned to their cars rapidly, driving into the plastic barrier set up on the road, fleeing the scene.

"It was only after the cars left that were were informed by Israel that one had been killed and five others injured," the official said.

Israel's Magen David Adom medical service said shots were fired at three vehicles, which evacuated to the nearby settlement of Har Bracha.

"After attempts at reviving him, a man of around 30 years was declared dead. A young man of 20 was seriously injured and a youth of around 17 was moderately wounded. Two others were lightly wounded," the medical service said.

According to Al-Bakri, "The Palestinian Authority has formed an investigating committee headed by Palestinian military intelligence and security department officials," noting that field investigations had begun and that guards at the scene had been detained for questioning.

Palestinian officers told Ma'an earlier that settlers had pulled their weapons and pointed them at the PA security, which had informed the settler group that they were not permitted to be in the area without an Israeli military guard.

Both Palestinian security and Israel's military confirmed no coordination attempts had been made for an escort for the settler group.

Security forces first fired warning shots into the air, according to Palestinian officials, while a statement from Israel's army said Palestinian officials said shots were fired "after identifying suspicious movements."

Yaakov David Ha'ivri, a settler leader in the northern West Bank, said the ncident put "a great question mark over the ability of the Palestinian Authority to protect the security of Jewish worshipers," he said. "It could encourage the Israeli side to take more responsibility."

Visits to the tomb, in the Nablus-area town of Balatta, have in the past years been conducted at night. Israeli forces enter the area and impose a military curfew, preventing civilians from leaving their homes from the hours of midnight to dawn.

Palestinian police operating in the area during a Israeli military operation are told to evacuate.

Palestinian Authority security services spokesman Adnan Dmeiri told Ma'an that officers on duty at the site had been summoned to give testimonies as witnesses to the incident, but said none had been detained.

Dmeiri said a committee had been formed to investigate the shooting but said it would not include Israeli officials. He denied media reports that the investigation would be under US supervision.

Mixed reactions

"This was an abnormal event which does not characterize the nature of the relationship," an Israeli military official told Ynet, a news site based in Tel Aviv. "It is possible that the group's failure to coordinate the visit caused a misunderstanding," the official said.

The governor of Nablus, Jibril Al-Bakri, added that the shooting was unintentional and said it was still being investigated.

The army said its senior officials were expected to meet with Palestinian security officers Sunday to examine the incident.

Israel's Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu in a statement denounced "an odious crime against Jewish faithful at prayer," and demanded that the Palestinian Authority (PA) "take severe measures" against those behind the attack.

Israeli Defense Minister Ehud Barak issued a statement "strongly condemning" the incident and calling on the army and Palestinian Authority to investigate.

"No breakdown in coordination can justify an event of this nature and firing at innocent people," he said.

Following the incident, Israeli forces closed the Beit Furik checkpoint east of Nablus and intensified inspections at Za'tara and Huwwara checkpoints in the area.

Clashes erupted around Joseph's Tomb as Israeli forces launched tear gas at young Palestinians protesting in the area.

After Israeli forces withdrew, Palestinians set fire to the site.

AFP contributed to this report
Print Send to friend
1 ) Julie / USA
24/04/2011 09:38
PA had every right to shoot, the violent settlers shot at them first...as always!! the big question is WHYYYY didn't the palestinian security forces ARREST the criminal settlers and throw them in jail???

2 ) Alon / Israel
24/04/2011 10:34
The murdered man lived in Jerusalem, was not a settler. This article is an excellent example of slanted journalism in which you attempt to manipulate facts to justify murder and terrorism. Of course, I doubt you'll have the nerve to print this comment but the truth is that the Palestinian security forces opened fire on 15 - get it, not DOZENS, but 15 unarmed civilians going to pray. You lose all credibility by attempting to make this into anything other than what it was. An attack on worshippers

3 ) Palestinian / Occupied Palestine
24/04/2011 11:48
To Alon lol @ "15 unarmed civilians" maybe you think you can fool others reading your full-of-lies-comment, but we Palestinians and you zionist colonists know EXACTLY that every settler occupying Palestinian land is ARMED!!!! They walk fully-armed inside the colonies and you expect people to believe that they entered Nablus unarmed?? Your lies dont work anymore because images of ARMED settlers walking Palestinian roads, entering Palestinian villages, entering holy places fill the internet.

4 ) Lukas / AntiZionist
24/04/2011 11:54
That the Zionist theocracy of Israel has insisted on an illegal occupation for 43 years, clearly shows the lunacy of its individuals in government. And, Alon Israel, who live in that lunatic state. If you have any other proof post it directly.

5 ) O / RLY?
24/04/2011 12:42
#2 he was a leader of the Jewish community in Shomron-WEST BANK!! dont't lie!!!-rules are rules man-no Palestinian without coordinating with the jews can't get into a settlement, and so no settler(every time they have to get a authorisation) cant go freely to Palestinian cities-settleres are dangerous, they rob, steal, burn land, shoot and kill- read the OCHA reports!! so jews can kill when they see a "suspicious movement" and you praise that, but the other way around is bad?nice hypocrisy man!!

6 ) Julie / USA
24/04/2011 13:13
#2 Alon Israel, doesn't matter who the man was, or even IF they weren't armed (everyone knows they WERE). regardless, they were ALL fully aware of the protocol to coordinate...but instead they intentionally defied the rules like israel always does. they are fully responsible for bringing this on themselves. the wicked bastards got exactly what they deserved, FINALLY. they are killing israel more and more while we wait to see the last breath out of israel's trench-rot mouth

7 ) ronen / israel
24/04/2011 13:18
never in my life have i seen or heard of a hassidic jew carrying a gun.
not only that the author is a liar but he also didnt sign his name on the piece.
i hope whoever did this is saying his goodbyes

8 ) Corey / Israel
24/04/2011 14:02
He lived in Jerusalem in a Breslov Hassidic neighborhood. Breslov Hassidim don't carry weapons- they believe god protects them.

9 ) poor / baby u
24/04/2011 14:50
#7 haha oh boy..... ok dude-read the IDF reports on what kind of settlers usualy attack them;] you will never guess hahahaha

10 ) Fadel / Nablus
24/04/2011 14:50
God bless him more resistance operations will follow against the enemy, a lot of the resistance groups are rearming :) ...

11 ) Fadel / Nablus
24/04/2011 14:54
And many resistance fighters have also infiltrated the pa security forces ;)

12 ) even the IDF shoot them and / arrest them!!
24/04/2011 15:01
After the events of October 2000, the IDF prohibited Israeli access to the tomb. However, some Breslov hasidim and others would visit the site clandestinely under the cover of darkness, evading army and police checkpoints. In May 2002, Israeli soldiers opened fire on a convoy of settlers taking advantage of an ongoing incursion in Nablus to visit the tomb. Seven settlers were arrested by the army for illegally entering a combat zone- from wikipedia heh but still a nice info-so what's the fuss??

13 ) Josre / PS
24/04/2011 15:34
@ ronen, it seems that you didn't get out of Tel Aviv. Settlers everywhere here in Westbank, they are all armed, they are harassing people all the time, they are using whatever they got to make our life miserable. how many palestinian were killed by Israeli in the check points? what happened is what it has to be done, these people are settlers, living in internationally called Illegal settlement, and their existence in settlements is illegal, how can they can be accepted to break into A

14 ) Waleed / Palestine
24/04/2011 16:19
Ronen , lets be fair , settlers possess weapons more than the IDF themselves , and they teach their kids how to use it (for the future).What would the IDF do if a Palestinian group did the same in Jerusalem (they would burn them alive because they are "a security threat" )

15 ) ronen / israel
24/04/2011 17:12
these people are claimed by al jazeera to be hassidim. meaning the ultra orthodox black clad jews. they are not the settlers you talk about. hassidim dont carry weapons. moreover maan is the only news outlet to have reported that they carried weapons. what happened here is the same thing that happened in lebanon a few months back. you murder and than try to justify it. by gallop poll israel is the seventh most happiest people on the planet. you arabs have failed. your tactics backfired since 40s

16 ) #8 You made me laugh, really / John
24/04/2011 18:14
They cannot take any single steps in the occupied Palestinian territories without holding their weapons and that could be directed to shot Palestinians at any time.

17 ) Fred / US
24/04/2011 20:15
Hum, this sounds like a perfect justification for the IDF to invade Lebanon, of perhaps Iran....

18 ) Tobias / US
24/04/2011 20:35

As Julie writes, the
"PA had every right to shoot, the violent elements" (settlers),
for their conduct today, and thus it is equally true that
Israel has every right to shoot, the violent elements (Arabs)
for their routine conduct, every today for the last few decades !!!!


19 ) Outsider / EU
24/04/2011 21:38
"Yaakov David Ha'ivri, a settler leader in the northern West Bank, said the incident put "a great question mark over the ability of the Palestinian Authority to protect the security of Jewish worshipers," No, actually. It puts a great question mark over the settlers willingness to abide by rules set out for their own safety. The death is sad, but the result of deliberate provocation.

20 ) Philip / Ireland
24/04/2011 21:39
In Hebron, it is possible to be unarmed and asleep in bed and yet be murdered by IDF soldiers. Impossible of course to compare this atrocity with the confrontation between armed PA security and armed Israeli persons ...!!!

21 ) Masud Ubaid / Egypt
24/04/2011 21:39
The Zionists are furious because they died is an Israeli settler, had been a Palestinian civilian would be nice because it is a terrorist, Israeli settlers constant provocation to the Palestinians supported by IDF
FREE PALESTINE IS COMING IN SEPTEMBER

22 ) Tobias / US
24/04/2011 23:32

Even if you believe the story, then you must recognize that
these settlers acted just like Palestinians have for decades:
- "They threw stones."
- "They tried to bypass a patrol in a parked jeep."
- "They carried out provocative acts".

However, if Israeli police acted like these Palestinian police,
- "fire first in the air and then open fire on their vehicles",
then dozens of Palestinians would be killed every single day !!!


23 ) Mohamad Shahin / NJ, USA
24/04/2011 23:35
Waleed is 100% right. They knew what they were supposed to do, they were very aware that they were supposed to coordinate to be allowed to enter, they didn't-enough said

24 ) Yehuda Solomon / Israel
24/04/2011 23:36
Despite all the points made by my fellow (Jewish) Israelis I have to admit the Israeli settlers who entered Joseph's Tomb did so ILLEGALLY. The fact remains they definitely SHOULD HAVE gotten permission and coordinated with the Palestinians, PERIOD. Where people are from or whether settlers are armed or unarmed is TOTALLY IRRELEVANT. When you have an agreed-upon policy in place, everybody FOLLOWS IT or you run the risk of people getting KILLED. Does everybody UNDERSTAND THIS ??? ...

25 ) Maureen / Australia
24/04/2011 23:44
7) ronen. It is alleged that three car loads of Zionists were acting suspiciously and tried to break through a West Bank checkpoint. Your mob want to live in Palestine, then they should obey Palestinian law!

26 ) ovadyah / Hales
25/04/2011 00:55
I suspect if we were privy to the conversation between G-d and Joseph . we would see and hear tears at the behavior of his people ... joseph was a example of patience and faith ..even in prison ... as for the hate that blocks the door to josephs tomb to the free entry by the desendant of his brothers ...G-d is about to remove that veil of hate...Palistinians can do it the easy way or face the personal appearance of God. the road map is in Gods Book.

27 ) ronny knape / usa
25/04/2011 01:18
liberate Palestine!

28 ) Michael Dugas / USA
25/04/2011 05:49
They were murdered by PA Police plain and simple. Does the PA co ordinate with Israel when they come in to blow up buses and murder women and children? The victim WASN'T a settler and was a Hassidic Jew. If they instigated it then where are the dead or injured PA Police? Murder.

29 ) Abban / America
25/04/2011 06:59
How can anyone of you be so cold? The Israeli army has restricted Jews from visiting JEWISH holy sites for fear of inciting violence. Meanwhile, Muslim Palestinians have unfettered access to their holy sites in Jerusalem and elsewhere. How can Palestinians live in peace when they take every opportunity to kill a Jew? Really?

30 ) Colin Wright / USA
25/04/2011 08:33
It'll be interesting to see how absurd Israel's demands get and whether the Palestinian Authority stands up to them. I recently went down to Baja California. I had to go through quite a few army checkpoints. Let's assume I had chosen to run one, and a Mexican soldier had shot me. I have a real hard time picturing the US condemning Mexico and forcing it to punish the soldiers involved.

31 ) noname / Palestine
25/04/2011 09:56
to 2,7 and 8 how many Palestinians were killed with the excuse of " they didn't obey officers orders" or attempting to run over an officer at a checkpoint. How can you even not look at that fact in this article or since its a Jew involved it does not count. or maybe since it is a Palestinian officer then it is not even considered for you

32 ) ... / XXX
25/04/2011 12:27
toTobias- there is a difference when a group of people run through a checkpoint,and the diff.is when an IDF kills sb in his bed,shoot peasant farming his land, kids playing near the wall, or a man who didn't hear the calling to stop having only a can of coca cola in his hand- you poor man, still don't see the difference-those settleres snuck into Nablus-IDF prohibited Isr access to the tomb.You want to shoot people throwing stones Tobias?!-so ok then Pals can shoot settlers like ducks since now!

33 ) U ARE SO FULL OF / ^%$&^
25/04/2011 12:32
TOBIAS-shoot ppl who throw stones?ok...read the OCHA report: EVERY DAY JEWS THROW STONES, BURN LAND AND ATTAKC PALS- SO FROM NOW ON PAL POLICE CAN SHOOT THEM RIGHT? EVEN JEWSISH KIDS- who throw stones...seriously read the reports!!! you missed the part when SETTLERS ATTACKED PALS FOR DECADES AND NO ONE COULD TOUCH THEM!!!

34 ) jk / kj
25/04/2011 12:37
tobias!!! since the beginning of illegal settlement, settlers attacked Pals- a fine thong to forget,eh?but only from this month, from OCHA report:subsequent wave of settler attacks against Palestinians and their property throughout the West Bank, the events of March 2011 continued to point to the heightened vulnerability of civilians in the occupied Palestinian territory. 28/1/11:Settlers Killing Palestinian Teenager in Arak Burin;13 march:Settlers Attack Palestinian Homes Near Nablus....

35 ) jk / kj
25/04/2011 12:39
9 April:Armed Settlers supported by Israeli army attack Palestinian village At 8.30am this morning around fifty settlers, some masked and armed with guns, descended from Yitzhar settlement onto the Palestinian village of Assira Al Qibliya. International observers from the UK and Ireland witnessed the settlers threw rocks at homes and people on the outskirts of the village injuring one local, who is being treated in hospital.21 march:Palest. worker stabbed in a West Bank settlement near Hebron...

36 ) jk / kj
25/04/2011 12:51
21march(that same day):settler shot and wounded two Pals at a funeral in Hebron, and much much more-nice to hide truth tobias!so then Pals now can react and shoot those settlers right-u have no objection I see.Settleres since the first settlement attack Pals-UN reports/archive-and Pals couldn't even defend themselves!and there is a difference between IDF shooting kids or peasants near the fence, man in bed or a man with a coke in his hand and a bunch of ppl running over a checkpoint!!!

37 ) Yepyep / Europe/West Bank
25/04/2011 14:41
#28: You wrote: "Does the PA co ordinate with Israel when they come in to blow up buses and murder women and children?" No, but when Palestinians want to visit holy sites in Jerusaslem, they do it with Israeli permission.
Maybe you are saying here, that these Jews (who didn't have their permissions) were coming to blow up busses and murder women and children? Otherwise they would have their permissions, like normal Palestinians have when visiting Jerusalem.

38 ) carine / UK
25/04/2011 15:50
#29
Unfettered access - really??
"The Passover holiday sees the Ibrahimi Mosque closed off to Muslims for Jewish-only worship and parts of the former downtown core blocked for Palestinians." Taken from an article on this very site!!

39 ) Tobias / US
25/04/2011 17:20
32-34,

You three are totally out of touch with reality**.
And, worse still, if Pals take your advice and start shooting Jews,
their "occupation" situation will only get much worse !!!

** out of touch with reality:
- IDF NEVER intentionally "shoot peasant farming his land or kids playing".
- If settlers have been so busy attacking Pals, then how do you explain,
that NO Palestinian villages have a security fences,
BUT every single settlement needs a security fence, from day one ??


40 ) Deir Yassin / Palestine/France
25/04/2011 19:57
Whether the guy was a settler ot not is irrelevant. We all know what the Border Police and the thugs in the IDF do to Palestinians who try to enter Israel illegally. They won't even climb the wall, before being killed. The guy was 24-years-old and already had 4 kids, preparing the future colonization of Palestine or what ? And what is a "Jerusalem resident" ? East or West Jerusalem ???

41 ) izzy / usa
25/04/2011 20:43
Regardless of all this chatter. When an israeli soldier shoots an unarmed palestinian, everybody goes nuts. Now a palestinian guard shooots an unarmed israeli THE SAME PEOPLE should go nuts as well.

42 ) poor tobias / rly poor
25/04/2011 21:04
wow you realy don't know NOTHING about occupation;] to build fences Pals have to get a permit(area B and C) they are not jews to build only fences...the actions of jews speak for them selves,and nothing you write will change that:)UN and human.org. write tons of report about that-read them!:) IDF NEVER intentionally shoot? hay! anything that will help you man:)a shot child or a peasant on their own land is still shot by IDF;] it is a difference when they DONT try to run over a checkpoint:)

43 ) to izzy / xyz
25/04/2011 22:18
those jews wanted to RUN OVER a checkpoint!! it is a difference when a Pal is killed in bed, holding a coke or when gets too near to a wall!!! you must be blind woman with the hate toward Pals not to see the difference!!! THEY TRIED TO RUN OVER A CHECKPOINT- DEAL WITH IT!!!!ps. so if you don't see the problem with every shooting of a Pal when it comes to "security" so why this time you think differently?in this case u must say as usually you do- and praise the Pal police for a good job!!!

44 ) jack / val
25/04/2011 22:35
oh tobias you are so lame...so it is Pal's fault that jews attack them??!!! hahahaha you will do anything to defend the jewish atrocities:) jewish actions speak for themselves man...deal with it:) they rob, burn land, shoot people ON DAILY BASIS-OCHA (UN) reports:) IDF is so slow when it comes to protect the Pals(area B and C)...and that is the truth- deal with it! settlers are dangerous and savage toward Pals- THEY ATTACK THEM DAILY!!! evidence you will find here:http://www.ochaopt.org/

45 ) carine / UK
25/04/2011 23:56
This immature 24-yr old should have been home with his wife and 4 kids, instead of going on a jolly in the middle of the night, thinking he was invincible. He knew the rules, he broke them, he paid the price.
#39
No Tobias, it is you who are out of touch with reality!
If these settlers weren't squatting on stolen Palestinian land, they wouldn't need security fences.
#41
This is a rare occurence. IDF shoot unarmed Palestinians, inc. children, on a regular basis.

46 ) American Back To The Indian / USA
26/04/2011 02:23
#1 you need remedial reading help. They were not settlers and it does not say they fired any shots. What a terrible crime, no permit to pray at the grave of their ancestor.

47 ) Ann / UK
26/04/2011 11:27
To 29 - 'unfettered access'? No Palestinian in the West Bank can travel anywhere outside own area without permit from Israel. Both Moslem and Christian Palestinins are refused permits and access to holy sites, especially those in Jerusalem. Over Easter hundreds of Christian Palestinians have been refused access to pray at the Holy Sites in Jerusaelm - as they are refused every year.

48 ) Abban @ Ann / America
27/04/2011 00:10
How would you know this Ann? Do you go to the West Bank? I know for a fact Palestinians have full access to holy sites, but in the case of security issues access is cut. Would you prefer people die and then the sites are closed off for months as they were years ago?

49 ) dont lie / Abban!!!
28/04/2011 14:20
#Abban: Los Angeles Times: "WEST BANK: Palestinian Christians denied access to holy places in Jerusalem during Easter"- read it! stop your stupid propaganda..."but in the case of security issues access is cut"- you have answerded your own stupid question- "security" always was an excuse that for some people was sufficient, but not for all! you live in your own small fantasy world but don't say it is reality!!!! jews don't give a damn about security, they do as they please,even IDF can't do much

50 ) dont lie / Abban!!!
29/04/2011 14:16
#Abban: Los Angeles Times: "WEST BANK: Palestinian Christians denied access to holy places in Jerusalem during Easter"- read it! stop your stupid propaganda..."but in the case of security issues access is cut"- you have answerded your own stupid question- "security" always was an excuse that for some people was sufficient, but not for all! you live in your own small fantasy world but don't say it is reality!!!! jews don't give a damn about security, they do as they please,even IDF can't do much
Name Country
Comment
Characters
Note: Comments will be reviewed for appropriate content. Click here for more details.

Share/Bookmark

Mursi orders military operation to free hostages
Man killed in Gaza tunnel collapse
Palestinian killed, 2 hurt in Lebanon clash

Close Next Previous
All Rights Reserved © Ma'an News Agency 2005 - 2013