اجعلنا صفحة البداية RSS خدمة Add to favorite Facebook Twitter

Advanced

Opinion: Prisoners have right to see family, read books
Published Thursday 19/04/2012 (updated) 12/05/2012 10:25

I knew, separately, Suheir Ismael and Najeeb Farraj before they became a couple.

I knew Najeeb as a colleague working with AFP and Al Quds daily, and an avid reader of the political scene in Palestine. I worked with Suheir when we produced the documentary Palestinian Diaries during the first Intifada. In it, Suheir talks about the day her brother was killed by Israelis while he was trying to help a neighbor in Al Khader village, near Bethlehem.

With her brother gone and her father killed in Lebanon, Suheir grew up a strong woman fighting for her rights in a male-dominated society. I will never forget the day she interviewed her mother for the documentary, asking her a tough question: Why didn't you follow dad into exile?

She later told me that the camera gave her the courage to ask a question she had not dared ask face-to-face.

Another documentary I co-produced documents her wedding day and includes a segment in which distant male relatives try to take advantage of her men-less family, only to be put down by Najeeb’s brother Hamdi, a leading Palestinian columnist.

Suheir moved to Najeeb’s home in Dheisheh camp and continued to work in film-making, setting up a media NGO that trains women filmmakers. She and Najeeb have also produced a lovely family.

When they were gifted with a son, they called him Ismael, in memory of Suheir’s dead brother. The name has given the young boy some trouble, as it matches the name of the deputy head of the Palestinian intelligence service, Ismael Farraj (who is Najeeb’s older brother).

The young Ismael, however, seems to have adopted points of view a little to the left of those of his pro-Fatah uncle. His leftist ideology has also incurred the wrath of the Israelis.

Described by friends and family as smart, clever and charismatic, the young Ismael Farraj became a supporter of the PLO's left-wing faction the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine. At Al Quds University, where Ismael is a second-year law student, he became involved in the PFLP’s student movement. As any active student, he would help with public events on and off campus.

Last October, Israeli soldiers sneaked into areas under Palestinian security rule and broke into the Farrajs’ home, in Dheisheh camp and arrested young Ismael. He was charged with belonging to an illegal organization.

Although the PFLP is part of the PLO, which has signed a memorandum of understanding with Israel in 1993, Israel has not removed the organization from their long list of organizations it considers to be terrorists.

Ismael is also accused of having prepared chairs for public events and inciting people to throw stones. He, himself, is not accused of any violent act.

Since Oct. 10, Ismael has been held at the Ofra detention facility near Ramallah. This is the first time Ismael was detained. His parents are banned from seeing him. No official explanation is given for this ban. Only his siblings, Lamis, 17, and Ruba, 14, are allowed to see him.

What is most upsetting to Ismael and his family is the relatively new Israeli policy (under premier Benjamin Netanyahu) that bans books from prisons or detention centers. Israelis are allowing only three books per year, and of those, only textbooks.

This week, Ismael, who was brought to a hearing, told his family that he wishes they could get him a world atlas, which apparently is allowed under this weird textbook policy.

Palestinians are also prevented from pursuing education in prison, including the ability to apply for the Tawjihi matriculation test and for college education.

Palestinian prisoners have declared a prison-wide hunger strike. It began with 1,200 prisoners demanding basic rights, such as family visits (those with family in Gaza have not seen relatives since 2007), the ability to touch and hug children and family members and to apply for high school and college degrees, as well as have regular books brought in.

They are also calling for an end to administrative detentions.

Israel violated international law when it transferred Gaza prisoners to Israel and has continued to flaunt international humanitarian law by preventing prisoners, since June 2007, to see their families. Barring parents also seems to be used as an unauthorized punishment, as in Ismael’s case.

It might help if international celebrities like George Clooney, Angelina Jolie and Richard Gere who have championed world issues would also champion these basic rights of Palestinians including that of family visits and the right of a parent even in prison to hug their children during visits.

It would be commendable to see Nobel Literature laureates sign a statement calling on Israel to stop the policy of banning books for Palestinian prisoners.

It would be great if universities around the world and academics would push Israel to allow prisoners to take the high school examination and enroll in distance college education.

It would be great if Jewish religious and secular leaders whose history and culture highlight the importance of books, and being a light unto nations, would protest the denial of books to Palestinian prisoners.

One might disagree with the cause of the conflict or the reasons for jailing people, but even prisoners have their rights protected and safeguarded by international law and basic common sense.

Ismael’s father expects his son to be sentenced to about two years.

The big question, however, for Ismael and all other prisoners, is what will happen once they end their prison term and what will they think of how the world acted when they were being punished.
Print Send to friend
1 ) model / prisoners
19/04/2012 15:59
Gilad Shalit was given no rights at all, while held by Hamas for years,
and Palestinian Prisoners deserve no such rights, even if they are "model prisoners", which they are clearly NOT at the moment.


2 ) Brian Cohen / Israel
19/04/2012 21:43
It is farcial how Palestinians invoke "international law" all the time, while they break it themselves. Palestinians held Gilad Shalit in violation of all international laws. Palestinians arrest their own journalists and human rights workers in violation of international laws. And, of course, both Amnesty and HRW concluded that thousands of Palestinian attacks against Israeli civilians are war crimes and crimes against humanity. Kuttab cries crocodile tears.

3 ) Colin Wright / USA
20/04/2012 02:06
re model #1 and Brian #2. Why don't you at least be honest? The prisoners have no rights because they are Palestinians -- you will never, never admit that any Palestinians have any rights under any circumstances. This has nothing to do with their behavior, nothing to do with how Gilat Shalit may or may not have been treated, and nothing to do with whatever other rationalizations you might cook up. The prisoners have no rights because they are Palestinians. That's all.

4 ) southparkbear / usa
20/04/2012 04:59
in jail you have no rights rather privileges can be gained for good behavior. those are not given for free.

5 ) Robby / USA
20/04/2012 06:59
For all those writers that normally cite the Geneva Convention when trying to disparage Israel, if you apply those standards (i.e. assume the two sides are at war) then wouldn't these prisoners be Prisoners of War? And if that is the case are they entitled to visitors and education?

6 ) johnny benson / usa
20/04/2012 19:09
...i find it ironic how muslims world wide cry human rights of all kinds for themselves...,while refusing any human rights to their own citizens,....this is true ,with very few if any exceptions....maybe turkey...but the n ask the kurds

7 ) Ahmed / Palestine
21/04/2012 12:37
So, Palestinian prisoners must continue to keep punished for challenging their oppressor in a violent or non-violent way! that punishment includes denying them family visits and reading books! How dare they challenge their oppressor? how dare they arrest a soldier like Gilad Shalit whose unit was only defending Israel by launching tank-shells into Gaza to stop Hamas nuclear rockets! How dare they demand justice, how dare they demand freedom ... Southparkbear, Johnny, Robby, Brain you win!

8 ) johnny benson / usa
21/04/2012 22:08
#7 ahmed......look at the history of the last 64 years....you could have had peace and your own palestine...in 48....the arabs chose war...again you had east jerusalem..and all of the west bank in 67....the arabs chose war instead.....your leaders turned down peace when barak and omert and rabin..offered a reasonable deal...always you fight...now its to late..sorry to say...in reality ahmed you want it all..dont you?

9 ) Colin Wright / USA
25/04/2012 00:07
To johnny #8 '#7 ahmed......look at the history of the last 64 years...' Why do you exhort Ahmed to 'look at history' -- and then cite the usual Zionist fantasy? I'm confused. In 1948, Israel began ethnic cleansing in earnest in March -- the Arab states didn't respond until May. In 1967, whatever else you may say, it was indubitably the Israelis that struck first. Neither Barak nor Olmert nor Rabin offered anything that could be construed as a 'reasonable deal' in any sane universe. Etc.

10 ) Colin Wright / USA
25/04/2012 00:14
To Johnny Benson: '..,while refusing any human rights to their own citizens,....this is true ,with very few if any exceptions....maybe turkey...' You're betraying your ignorance. If not necessarily model democracies, at a minimum Morocco, Tunisia, Bosnia, Jordan, and Malaysia are all states where there is some rule of the law and the inhabitants enjoy more real rights than -- say -- Palestinians in Israel.

11 ) Ahmed / Palestine
26/04/2012 10:48
@#8 Golda Mier said once that she will not return the West Bank because there is nobody to return it to. Shamir said that he will negotiate with the Palestinians for ever and give them nothing, (which pretty much what is happening) in your history he doesn't exist. current PM said he will interpret the peace process in a way to make it impossible to withdraw from the West Bank. your version of history suggests he is a liar! We r nothing but a game for you to play us around and fool us! well done

12 ) Brian Cohen / Israel
01/05/2012 17:18
Colin does not speak for me, especially when he is wrong. All prisoners do indeed have universal human rights. However, this does not include a college education and other perks. Does international law say they are entitled to family visits? I doubt it. A lawyer, yes. The Red Cross yes. Aside from that, what are they being denied? Freedom, of course, but they forfeited that by committing violent crimes. And I agree that admin detention prisoners be charged and tried, or released.

13 ) southparkbear / usa
02/05/2012 06:10
ok i give up. send picture we'll pass it on to prisoners

14 ) Colin Wright / USA
02/05/2012 21:02
To Brian Cohen #12 '...but they forfeited that by committing violent crimes...' Actually Brian, as a rule, those Palestinians who are caught actually committing violent acts (you call them crimes, but I don't) never make it to prison. This is Israel. They're shot without trial. Or, as in one famous case, their heads are beaten in with rocks. Again, this is Israel.

15 ) @ Ahmed #11 / USA
06/05/2012 19:01
You are probably just making those Mier & Shamir quotes up, but, there may be some truth to, "there is nobody to return Area C to", and obviously "negotiating with the Palestinians" earned Fatah's return from Tunisia, and self-governing the Areas A/B and Gaza. Everyone's "version of history suggests the Fatah were the liars", since they promised a peace process, to collect weapons, etc., but won't talk and encourage violence, and even started days of rage (Intifadas) !!!

16 ) Tony B? / ME
09/05/2012 12:14
"Hamas Minister of Interior and National Security, Fathi Hammad recently said that Palestinians actually came from Egypt, Yemen and Saudi Arabia. In an interview he gave to Al-Hekma TV, an Egyptian network, he discussed the necessity of Arab-Muslim solidarity and the support the Gazans need from the Egyptians to continue with their Jihad efforts". Let them read this. The truth will set you free! Hamas has blown all your claims out of the water! Even Colin Wright can't slither out of this one !
Name Country
Comment
Characters
Note: Comments will be reviewed for appropriate content. Click here for more details.

Share/Bookmark

Analysts: Mursi cuts Syria ties to woo West, boost image
Has the Obama-Kerry charm offensive failed?
Rowhani 'tone' may reopen doors for Iran

Close Next Previous
All Rights Reserved © Ma'an News Agency 2005 - 2013