اجعلنا صفحة البداية RSS خدمة Add to favorite Facebook Twitter

Advanced

Opinion: Does the world have room for Battir village?
Published Sunday 03/06/2012 (updated) 08/06/2012 00:58
Battir village, once the bread basket of Bethlehem and Jerusalem, now
faces high unemployment and risk to its unique cultural heritage due to
Israel's occupation and separation wall. (MaanImages/Stringer)

Battir, a Palestinian village south west of Jerusalem, has a charming, rural landscape which was recently recognized by UNESCO with the Melina Mercouri International Prize for the Safeguarding and Management of Cultural Landscapes.

Battir also has had a unique agreement with Israel since 1949. The Rhodes Armistice Agreements, signed during the period of Jordanian rule over the West Bank, was implemented by Israeli military leader Moshe Dayan, Hassan Mustafa and six others from Battir village.

The agreement confirms that "Battir inhabitants will continue having ownership to their lands falling in the Jewish Territory."

But since that day Israel's military occupation and now the separation barrier have had devastating effects on the people and the land of Battir.

These detrimental effects are felt across the region, where human security is under constant threat and every aspect of life has been affected, including health, education, agriculture, employment and infrastructure.

The town has collectively experienced land expropriation, the destruction of agriculture, including olive and fruit trees that served as a source of income, settlement expansion, and isolation from other West Bank communities.

Other threats include the lack of urban networks and tools to mitigate the urban encroachment on the area, in particular landfills and Israeli dumps that pollute the earth and the precious water sources.

If the situation does not improve, Battir's ecological and environmental equilibrium will continue to be threatened and its residents denied the chance to enjoy their natural heritage and sustain the land.

The UNESCO World Heritage Committee has expressed its regret that the prevailing situation in Palestine is not conducive to the smooth and effective implementation of conservation programs.

It has called for a collective effort to safeguard Palestinian cultural and natural heritage and take measures to prevent further damage to these areas.

Battir, along with other cluster villages, boast long histories, religious and archeological sites as well as close proximity to some of the most beautiful landscapes in Palestine.

The area is dotted with fertile valleys and ridges, hand-carved terraces for the cultivation of olives, almonds, grapes and other fruit trees, and water springs and caves.

But the community of Battir, with a population of about 4,500 people, face severe social, economic and political realities.

As with all communities located in the so-called Areas B and C, Battir is under Israeli control. Due to the village's proximity to Israeli settlements, the Green Line and Jerusalem, land confiscation is a constant threat.

To illustrate this point, Battir received five Israeli military orders to seize villages lands between 2004 and 2011.

The majority of this land is natural open space, including forest and agricultural land, which is the basic source of livelihood for the inhabitants. Battir was known in the past as the bread basket for the population of both Bethlehem and Jerusalem.

During the last decades, up to 65 percent of the work force relied on the Israeli labor market for employment. But since the second intifada even this source of employment has dropped drastically.

For Palestinians, work in Israel is not a stable source of income, as it is dependent on political factors, such as the procurement of hard-to-get permits and access. The unemployment rate in the village has risen to 40 percent.

Palestinian youth face a particularly difficult set of challenges. The high drop-out rates and poor quality of education in the area have ultimately led to increasing unemployment, criminal behavior and drug-use among youth.

Upon receiving a sub-standard education, local Palestinian students emerge into a world of responsibilities with an unsteady sense of self, ill-equipped to deal with the challenges they face in a complex conflict setting.

Israelis claim security reasons and fear of survival for their oppressive and racist policies in the occupied Palestinian territories. Even a binding UN agreement made 64 years ago is ignored, as if Israelis themselves were not signatories to it.

Israel's insistence on building the separation wall in Battir, ignoring all international agreements, and destroying the finest and oldest terracing for agriculture and irrigation system in the world -- these are not the best ways to solve Israeli existential fears.

As the monk of the nearby Mar Saba monastery is famed to have said to a lion that tried to attack him: "There is always a place for more than one." He lived in harmony with the lion in a single cave until they both died.

Fear and aggression do not bring security, and justice is the only key to peace. If what is spent on war were spent on fighting poverty and ignorance, the world would be safer, calmer and more just for everyone.

Occupiers will not enjoy peace until they commit themselves to justice, acknowledge and respect the rights of the indigenous population and end the occupation. Occupation cannot and will not last forever.

The day will come when Palestinians will be free and masters of their own destiny. The sooner Israel admits its part in the dispossession and oppression of Palestinians, the better for the whole world.

Ghassan Olayan is a Palestinian writer from Battir village.
Print Send to friend
1 ) Carol Scheller / Switzerland
04/06/2012 09:41
The Bar Saba monk's words epitomize the hospitality all visitors to Palestine experience. Palestine's neighbour, so unwelcoming to foreign immigrants, expecially black asylum seekers, as opposed to foreign investors and tourists, would do well to heed his wisdom : When there is always room for one more, there is a way to crafting the end to occupation and injustice. It starts in the heart. And Switzerland is not exempt !

2 ) @ Carol-1 / The Opposite Is True
04/06/2012 15:36
If Israel were so "unwelcoming to foreign immigrants, expecially black asylum seekers", why didn't the foreign immigrants just stop in Egypt ??

Also, there is NO "risk to its unique cultural heritage due to Israel's occupation and separation wall". In fact just the opposite is true !!!

3 ) Marry miller / USA
04/06/2012 17:15
Will , you have good points .

"Occupation cannot and will not last forever".
"justice is the only key to peace"

"The sooner Israel admits its part in the dispossession and oppression of Palestinians, the better for the whole world."





4 ) @ Mary-3 / USA too
04/06/2012 20:19
Israel DOES ALREADY "admit its part in the dispossession and oppression of Palestinians", which resulted from the joint Arab invasions in 1948 & 1967.
- That is NOT THE PROBLEM.

The "Palestinian" terrorists and the Arab invader States (Egypt, Jordan, Syria, Lebanon, Iraq, etc.) must also "admit their part in the dispossession" and accept their responsibility, for creating Israel's legitimate border/demographic security concerns !!!
- Until that, the whole world will NOT get any better.

5 ) ermana / USA
05/06/2012 16:59
Zionists like Mary can bury their heads in the sand all they want. The whole world is slowly gaining the courage to tell the truth about Israel's nefarious past and present. Israel has become the old Apartheid South Africa, and that is why the BDS campaign is spreading. Truth will out and justice will prevail.

6 ) ali juma,ah / palestiane
05/06/2012 17:29

The Israelis have to be frank to themselfes and understand that the Palestine have the Wright to live like them not under dogas is now.

sooner or later the hestory will chaeng .


7 ) David / US
05/06/2012 18:43
The actions of the apartheid state of Israel continue unabated. The writer of this piece points out the existence of an agreement brokered by Moshe Dayan that should offer protection from land theft by Israel. Time and time again, Israel has shown its disregard for international law, and its repression of any and all who dissent, including Israeli Jews. I thank the author and all those who struggle against tyranny.

8 ) Julia / US
05/06/2012 20:32
The wall of separation is collective punishment. It destroys Palestinian communities, both economically and culturally. The illegal settlements which appropriate land rightfully belonging to Palestinian families, are encouraged by the Israeli government while the original owners lose their livelihoods, their family homes, and their wells. Worst of all, and so sad for this American Jew to see, are the pogroms perpetrated upon these dispossessed people by Jewish settlers. What has happened to us?

9 ) Diana / USA
06/06/2012 09:07
The Israeli experiment has failed. It is past time for a single democratic secular state in all Palestine. Equal rights for all. What has happened to the Palestinians, and continues to happen, is a crime against humanity. Justice will eventually prevail, and beautiful villages like Battir will again thrive and can receive visitors. I will want to go there.

10 ) sara / US
06/06/2012 14:19
The Author in Really a good Palestinian

11 ) jojo / palestine
06/06/2012 14:39
we support all the point in this anticle

12 ) Tibi / Tubas
06/06/2012 22:05
Both sides agreed that final status issues can NOT be pre-judged, but the PLO continues to seek to avoid keeping this promise, and the main reason for this issue, and for other PLO initiatives, is so that Palestinians can have the United Nations to say that "Battir is in Palestine", which it won't be until Israeli negotiations are finalized, just like settlements won't be part of Israel until negotiations are finalized either !!!


13 ) Shery / France
07/06/2012 15:34
Life without freedom = 0

14 ) jamal / jordan
07/06/2012 17:37

Palestian was mentined in old payble more than 250 times and the same for palestinain and now isrealy and jeawsh would like to get us from the map , as the auther mr. olayan said "justice is the only key to peace" but i think the other alatrnative of justice and peace is the war.



15 ) mohamad\ battir / palestine
08/06/2012 23:38
the author opinion represents all of the Palestinian not only in west bank or Gaza but in the whole world and i agree with him about all the issues he raise in his great article because he is right and he also describes the real situation in Palestine because some of the news about Israel aren't right so i strongly agree with him.

16 ) Nasser salama / UAE/Dubai
09/06/2012 12:31
I support all the point in this anticle The Author in Really a good Palestinian

17 ) Carol Scheller / Switzerland
09/06/2012 20:24
Diana (9), you would love visiting Battir now, and you can. Call :
The Alternative Tourism Group
74 Star Street, P.0. Box 173
Beit Sahour, Palestine
Phone: 972 2 277 2151

or

Name Country
Comment
Characters
Note: Comments will be reviewed for appropriate content. Click here for more details.

Share/Bookmark

Analysis: Salam Fayyad doomed by Israeli and Palestinian enemies alike
Saeb Erekat: 65 years of impunity
Israel army doubts third intifada but on alert

Close Next Previous
All Rights Reserved © Ma'an News Agency 2005 - 2013