اجعلنا صفحة البداية RSS خدمة Add to favorite Facebook Twitter

Advanced

Israel slams UN agency over aid to displaced Palestinians
Published Sunday 15/07/2012 (updated) 17/07/2012 11:41
A young resident of south Hebron hills village Susiya is pictured beside
tented homes now slated for demolition by Israeli forces.
(MaanImages/Eva Pilipp, File)
BETHLEHEM (Ma'an) -- Israel's military department governing civil affairs in the occupied West Bank regards a UN agency's assistance to displaced Palestinians as illegal operations, a spokesman said Sunday.

Israeli daily Haaretz reported earlier that the department, the Coordinator of Government Activities in the Territories, with the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, are seeking to "reassess" the role of the UN Office for Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs in the West Bank.

The UN office "are assisting Palestinian communities who have demolitions because they are built in an illegal way. OCHA gives them tents and by that is doing illegal work, without seeking Israeli permission," COGAT spokesman Guy Inbar told Ma'an.

Humanitarian officials say providing a temporary tent to a displaced family falls under international definitions of emergency humanitarian assistance, rather than a building project that requires a permit.

Israeli authorities insist there is a legal process for Palestinians living in Area C, the 62 percent of the West Bank under full Israel civil and security control since the 1993 Oslo Accords, to build in their communities.

"In the last year (COGAT) approved many international projects, even UN OCHA projects, but not in an illegal way, like what they are doing in the south Hebron hills," Inbar said, while warning: "International work does not get immunity."

But the United Nations and humanitarian agencies say in reality it is almost impossible for Palestinians to obtain a building permit, and highlight that Israeli settlers in the same area are able to expand communities that are illegal under international law.

The south Hebron hills is one area of the West Bank facing repeated demolition orders. Israeli forces last month warned that they intend to demolish all 50 buildings in one village in the region, Susiya, after a settler group filed a legal petition calling for its removal.

A diplomatic source told Ma'an: "It is outrageous that (the Israeli) administration which condones illegal settlement construction is here using an argument against construction that helps some of the most disadvantaged communities, who have the right to protection under international law."

Already in 2012, Israeli authorities have demolished 330 Palestinian buildings in the West Bank, displacing 536 people, half of whom are children, the UN Special Rapporteur on human rights in the occupied Palestinian territories Richard Falk said in late June.

Meanwhile international law experts say that under the Fourth Geneva Convention Israel must provide for the needs of the occupied Palestinian population, and are prohibited from demolishing any structure that has a civilian purpose.

Haaretz reported that COGAT asked the Foreign Ministry to lodge a formal complaint with the UN, and on July 10 Israel’s UN ambassador wrote to the UN humanitarian affairs chief asking for staff lists, past and future activities and a review of the agency's role.

Israeli authorities are considering limiting visas for foreign OCHA employees and stopping work and travel permits for Palestinian staff members, the newspaper said.

Inbar said COGAT is perturbed that OCHA is over reaching its mandate through its work in Area C, while OCHA says it does not undertake building projects but is mandated to coordinate international agencies' response to humanitarian emergencies.
Print Send to friend
1 ) Mel / USA
15/07/2012 21:15
Pardon my "french" but.....no,you barbarian,colonial,Zionist criminal M/F ers!
The 'illegal operation..' is Israeli,USG,UKG state-sponored collusive 'international work' of a half century of persecution,alienation,expulsion,murder &torture of the VERY indigenous Arab Palestinian people who are suffering now & can only survive thru' whatever "aid",charity,they can get while USG/Zionist collective ethnic punishment CONTINUES,illegally!So screw all U crooked,racketeering,Zionist parasites!

2 ) @ Mel / USA too
15/07/2012 23:49
It is NOT your "french" that requires pardoning, but YOUR IGNORANCE: - Those you call "barbarians" lead the world, per capita, in scientific innovation. - It is NOT a "colonial" practice, since it was once BOTH Jewish land, on a Jewish state, which NO honest Palestinian can claim. - Loving your nation ("Zionist") is NOT "criminal", but - you "M/Fing" Racism is Criminal !!!!

3 ) Judo / Canada
15/07/2012 23:55
The article does not mention Palestinians also constructed more than 40,000 new homes last year.

4 ) BDS / Canada
16/07/2012 01:13
Someday there will be justice and these zionist war crimes will be punished. Global solidarity with the peoples of Palestine is getting stronger every day. The world will no longer turn a blind eye to these atrocities. Good for the UN for supporting the families and children of Susiya.

5 ) Brother of Mel / US
16/07/2012 01:46
Well said

6 ) ian / australia
16/07/2012 02:43
"...the UN Office for Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs...gives them tents and by that is doing illegal work..." No comment. Let us just quietly savour what Israel has become.

7 ) Zionist criminal M/F ers / nice goinl MEL
16/07/2012 02:59
At least you get free expression here Anti Semitism is an INCURABLE DISEASE!

8 ) tarek saba california / usa
16/07/2012 08:45
^^^^^ exactly what mel said

9 ) Colin Wright / USA
16/07/2012 10:41
To Ian #6. I'm not sure 'savor' is quite the right word -- but I certainly agree with the sentiment. They're so far gone they actually think they have grounds for complaint. What's next?

10 ) Colin Wright / USA
16/07/2012 10:43
To Judo #6 'The article does not mention Palestinians also constructed more than 40,000 new homes last year.' And why should it? The article is about how Israel objects to the UN giving tents to Palestinians after Israel knocks their houses down.

11 ) Colin Wright / USA
16/07/2012 10:44
To Zionist #7 'Anti Semitism is an INCURABLE DISEASE!' Given this story, what would you define Israel as?

12 ) @ Colin-11 / USA
16/07/2012 14:15
This story is about UN officials going to Israeli controlled territory,
and disregarding it's sovereignty & national rules, and NOT "Anti Semitism".

I am sure that if Israel, or any other state went to the UN General Assembly, and disregarded it's rules, THERE WOULD BE CONSEQUENCES.


13 ) Carlos / USA
16/07/2012 14:53
Since when is leading the world in per capita output an excuse for commiting war crimes? Nazi Germany was leading the world per capita output and thier excuse did not work. Anti semitism is not an issue in problems between Pals and israelis. Pals are semites too. Semitism does not mean Jewish. Semitism means a family of languages and does not refer to people at all. When someone says anti semite they are showing they are ignorant .

14 ) Mel / USA
16/07/2012 14:57
#2:'lead the world, per capita,in scientific innovation'? U mean WEAPONS,subbed by OUR US tax-dollars!If U were generalizing re:brilliant Jewish people/culture,then I agree?The JEWISH people have given the world some of the finest scientists,writers,thinkers,musicians,composers etc.Equating similar brilliance among Arabian scholars,for millenia. But,U are referring to radical fundamentalism i.e.19th C. Eurasian Zionism! A killing machine ONLY,& illegally colonizing pluralistic Palestine,post WW1

15 ) Tibi / Tubas
16/07/2012 16:54
Israel rightfully should "slams UN agency over aid",
since these initially "Palestinians displaced themselves",
- by moving onto lands they never legally owned, and
- by putting up temporary tents on it !!!

Israel law now forces the Palestinians to pay their own demolition costs, and
Israel, should do the same "slam" to the UN Office of Humanitarian Affairs !!!

16 ) southparkbear / usa
16/07/2012 18:19
i look at this as a nice side kick, palestinians violates the rules and we go and kick their you know what. However, I recommend removing each and every privilege given to UN. Treat them as suspect terrorists since that's what they are

17 ) Giacomo / USA
16/07/2012 20:52
Israel is not saying don't put up the tents... Israel is saying that per the Oslo Accord, Israel is responsible for this area (C), so work through the proper channels to put up legal housing. (Yes, settlements in the West Bank are and must continue to be dismantled too.). When it was reported in Ma'an that illegal Palestinian homes were demolished in Gaza recently, even Hamas was exercising its right to control illegal growth in areas of their jurisdiction.

18 ) Colin Wright / USA
17/07/2012 00:21
I was curious to see if any Israel-lovers would have the gall to rationalize Israel's action. Yup, there were a few great souls. A collective Chutzbah prize to be shared by '@', Tibi, Southpark, and Giacomo. You guys are all heart. Just hope that you never have to receive what you so zestfully dish out.

19 ) Giacomo / USA
17/07/2012 15:59
And therein lies the crux of 100 plus years of armed conflict between the Palestinians and the Israelis... the other party having the 'gall' to not have the 'right' position on the issue, and bestowing upon them a thinly veiled threat, or worse. Anyone can understand those who think just like us... attempting to understand another's POV takes true humanity.

20 ) @ Colin-18 / USA too
17/07/2012 16:05
Try and think about it objectively. What would happen if you setup a tent in NYC's Central Park, or if I setup a tent in your back yard ??

The Oslo Accords are a bilateral agreement between the PA & Israel,
which includes full Israeli administrative/military control in Area C,
where all of these issues are taking place !!!


21 ) Carlos / usa
17/07/2012 19:38
20 you are not objective.

22 ) southparkbear / usa
18/07/2012 02:53
I agree with carlos, if you are not pro palestinians by definition you are not objective

23 ) Crispo Galeon / Philippines
20/07/2012 10:57
At first, the land was called Canaan, then Palestine, and now Israel. From the naming and re-naming of the place alone, one can sense something went wrong somewhere. Winners and the victorious by virtue of their might and power wrote history and claimed the lands of the vanquished and the defeated as their own. Through the ages they handed down history presenting it as endless and timeless truth. It was the British that sanctioned the Zionists of Israel to occupy Palestine, fomenting the Nakba.

24 ) hilmi / Malaysia
20/07/2012 14:24
we wait and see ! pro Palestinian .. UN agency has right in everything.. why Israel administration is so dump.. unless they want to control the world by lie with their money power only.. No mercy on the Jewish over people and it's administration of State of IzraHell !! Never heard of ... Israel state or tribe only ???

25 ) Maureen / Australia
21/07/2012 00:07
16) kickarseparkbear, Zionist bully boy! Zionazis are already taking away Palestinian human rights privileges!

26 ) To #20 / EU
21/07/2012 16:30
If you build your house and your back yard on my land, I would do much more than just to setup a tent!

27 ) ian / australia
22/07/2012 12:40
#19 "Anyone can understand those who think just like us... attempting to understand another's POV takes true humanity." I agree Giacomo. But the POV of someone who needs a tent because they have nowhere else to live is quite easy to understand. So the real question is why it is beyond #2, #3, #7, #12, #15, #16, #20 and #22 (but of course you answered that already.)
Name Country
Comment
Characters
Note: Comments will be reviewed for appropriate content. Click here for more details.

Share/Bookmark

Hamas says talks underway to reopen Rafah crossing
Mursi orders military operation to free hostages
Egypt closes Gaza crossing for third day

Close Next Previous
All Rights Reserved © Ma'an News Agency 2005 - 2013