اجعلنا صفحة البداية RSS خدمة Add to favorite Facebook Twitter

Advanced

Australia: No sign Zygier involved in Hamas assassination
Published Wednesday 06/03/2013 (updated) 08/03/2013 16:47
Australian Foreign Minister Bob Carr talks to journalists during a news
conference in Sydney March 6. (Reuters/Daniel Munoz)
SYDNEY (Reuters) -- Australia has no evidence that an emigrant to Israel who died in an Israeli jail in 2010, had been involved in the assassination of a Hamas arms procurer in Dubai, Foreign Minister Bob Carr said on Wednesday.

Carr said Ben Zygier had worked for the Israeli government when he was arrested, but stopped short of confirming he worked for the Mossad security service. He also said there was no evidence of misuse of any of the Australian passports taken out by Zygier, legally issued to him under new names.

However, Carr said the case raised unresolved questions about Australian passports held by dual citizens who work for a foreign government, and said Australia would lodge the strongest possible protest if it was found that Israel had used an Australian passport for spying.

"We have our own sources. None of them have information at this time that one of his passports was misused. But we are very alive to the possibility," Carr said as he released a Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade report into the case.

"Certainly we would regard it as intolerable that any government would make use of Australian passports for intelligence-gathering purposes."

Zygier was arrested in February 2010 and charged with security offenses that have not been made public. At around the same time, Australia had complained to the Israelis after its passports had been used in a mission to kill a Hamas arms dealer in Dubai, which the Gulf emirate blamed on Mossad.

On Feb. 19 this year, Israel confirmed for the first time the affair concerned Zygier, who had earlier been named in an Australian Broadcasting Corporation television report.

One of Zygier's lawyers later linked him to Mossad, the Israeli spy agency. An expose aired by Israel's Channel Two television on Monday said that a senior Mossad official attended Zygier's funeral in his hometown of Melbourne. Many other details of the case remain the subject of gag orders in Israel.

A judicial inquiry in Israel found Zygier, 34, hanged himself in December 2010 with a sheet tied to the bars over a window in the bathroom of the heavily guarded cell where had been kept under alias and secluded from other prisoners.

Carr ordered an investigation into the case last month, saying he would ask Israel's government to explain how Zygier, a father of two who had lived in Israel for 10 years, managed to kill himself while tightly supervised. His death fueled conspiracy theories in both countries. Israel says it is investigating possible negligence by prison guards.

Carr said Israel had not responded to requests for information, nor explained the lack of a response. Australian officials and intelligence agencies still did not know why Zygier was jailed and what charges he faced, except that the charges carried a maximum penalty of up to 20 years in prison.

'Security affair of the utmost gravity'

Israel has said Zygier consented to his secret detention, to stem what it deemed as dangers to national interests from his exposure. That assertion has not been contested by his lawyers.

"This was a security affair of the utmost gravity. The damage to national security that was liable to have been caused, and apparently was caused, was most grave," Israeli prosecutor Raz Nizri told Israel's Channel One television on Tuesday.

Carr's inquiry found shortcomings in the handling of the case by Australian authorities, but noted that Zygier had received 50 visits from his family and lawyer between the time of his arrest and death.

Carr had initially said the Australian government had not been informed of Zygier's incarceration. He later acknowledged Australia's chief intelligence agency had been informed about the issue as early as February 2010.

Kevin Rudd, Australia's prime minister at the time of Zygier's arrest, on Wednesday said he was not informed of the arrest by his own intelligence agencies.

Rudd also said he was not told of Zygier's detention ahead of his visit to Israel as foreign minister from Dec. 12 to Dec. 14, 2010, when he met both Israel's prime minister and foreign minister. Zygier died in custody on Dec. 15.
Print Send to friend
1 ) Maureen / Australia
06/03/2013 21:29
Yeah right Mr Carr, nobody knows nuthin! And Australia's Opposition deputy leader has this to say on today's A News: "Opposition targets Smith, Rudd over Zygier case" http://www.abc.net.au/news/2013-03-06/opposition-targets-rudd-smith-over-zygier-case/4557314 Australia's good 'friend,' Israel, would not be deceitful to the Australian government - would it?

2 ) gabi / australia
07/03/2013 00:50
One local newspaper report here said that there was an agreement between Israeland Australia's intelligence (?) agencies, Mossad and ASIO that neither country would use the others' citizens for spying. I assume they meant in cases where there was dual citizenship. But the most amazing part is that ASIO seemed a bit peeved that they could not rely on Israel keeping to that agreement!

3 ) ariel / russia
07/03/2013 02:22
so what

4 ) Colin Wright / USA
07/03/2013 02:54
'...except that the charges carried a maximum penalty of up to 20 years in prison.' Well, it's not exactly out of the bag, but it's pretty that whatever is in there is a pretty big animal. You don't get twenty years for repeating that Israel steals passports. Compared to this, Israel handled Vanunu with kid gloves. So what was Zygier about to spill? Stay tuned...

5 ) Colin Wright / USA
07/03/2013 03:02
'Carr's inquiry found shortcomings in the handling of the case by Australian authorities...' There were also -- quite obviously -- major shortcomings in the handling of the case by Israeli authorities. Exactly what those shortcomings were, of course, depends on how you look at it.

6 ) Colin Wright / USA
07/03/2013 03:06
My own belief is that Zygier -- being from a wealthy background and first-world country and all -- wasn't going to play ball and let himself be quietly thrown into the hole until whatever he was going to spill would have been ancient history. He wanted his trial. He was going to spill the beans. The fool didn't realize he was in Israel. That's why he wound up 'hanging himself.'

7 ) Mel / USA
07/03/2013 17:21
"Prisoner X" was in lock-down 4"treason". ? he was about to blow a BIG WHISTLE on terrorist-state Israel's covert ops?So Israel topped him in the same"suicide-proof"cell built 4 Yitzhak Rabin's supposed killer Yigal Amir(1995)."If I were to tell the whole truth, the entire system would collapse. I know enough to destroy this country."(Yigal Amir).
http://www.news.com.au/national-news/foreign-minister-bob-carr-slams-dfat-in-prisoner-x-review/story-fncynjr2-1226591693674

8 ) ian / australia
07/03/2013 21:54
So Australian FM Bob Carr has been OK'ed to feign indignation about Israeli spies using our passports and to grandstand a bit threatening to lodge "the strongest possible protest" if Israel is ever caught doing it (which it wasn't in the Ben Zygier case). Tel Aviv must be quaking in their boots! He's still being told nothing ("Carr said Israel had not responded to requests for information, nor explained the lack of a response") which is faintly amusing and the whole thing has the strong air of

9 ) ian / australia
07/03/2013 22:05
(contd.) Israel calling the shots, determining what can be disclosed (like the 50 visits from his family and lawyer), what will be buried forever, and what people like FM Carr can say. Carr is permitted the gaudy and irrelevant revelation that Ben Zygier had no involvement in the killing of Mahmoud Mabhouh (by muscle relaxant and suffocation). We should care why exactly? There are a few weird new touches: "Israel has said Zygier consented to his secret detention, to stem what it deemed as danger

10 ) ian / australia
07/03/2013 22:09
(contd.) to national interests from his exposure." Say what? And one can speculate about what "security affair of the utmost gravity" carries a "maximum penalty of up to 20 years" (as opposed to life or the "high jump"). But all in all, the story is over, case closed, the official version has entered history. RIP Ben Zygier and the truth about his death.

11 ) ian / australia
07/03/2013 22:23
(contd.) Israel calling the shots, determining what can be disclosed (like the 50 visits from his family and lawyer), what will be buried forever, and what people like FM Carr can say. Carr is permitted the gaudy and irrelevant revelation that Ben Zygier had no involvement in the killing of Mahmoud Mabhouh (by muscle relaxant and suffocation). We should care why exactly? There are a few weird new touches: "Israel has said Zygier consented to his secret detention, to stem what it deemed as danger

12 ) ian / australia
08/03/2013 22:13
#4, #7 I'm not so sure about the "BIG WHISTLE"/"pretty big animal" idea. I think he was a defective spy, having been exposed (and interviewed) by ASIO, with a ruthless employer who would NOT let him come in from the cold. I don't see an "explosive revelation" as necessary in the Mossad play book. I think he was compromised, of no further use and a liability. And I don't think treason likely either. He doesn't seem a master dissembler like Kim Philby. Or cunning. Or resourceful. Or cynical.

13 ) ian / australia
08/03/2013 22:14
(contd.) He seems a naive, trusting schmoe who bought everything ever sold him. I mean, of all the bunk he was told, what DIDN'T he buy? Judaism, Zionism, Aliyah, Mossad. He's a patsy. And his chipper attitude, "rationally weighing his legal options", bears it out. Seems he really EXPECTED due process and a trial to argue his case or just throw himself at the mercy of the courts. Boy, did he get that wrong! And I don't really see him having beans to spill, more like, "Your honour, there's been a

14 ) ian / australia
08/03/2013 22:14
(contd.) terrible mistake! Let me explain." Naive to the end when he was paid the final visit.
Name Country
Comment
Characters
Note: Comments will be reviewed for appropriate content. Click here for more details.

Share/Bookmark

Israeli forces detain 5 Palestinians from Jenin
Hunger-striker agrees to Gaza deportation for 10 years
France seeks to brand Hezbollah as 'terrorist' group

Close Next Previous
All Rights Reserved © Ma'an News Agency 2005 - 2013