اجعلنا صفحة البداية RSS خدمة Add to favorite Facebook Twitter


3 Palestinians killed in Israeli airstrike on al-Maghazi home
Israel pushes force-feed law to break Palestinian hunger strike
Published Wednesday 11/06/2014 (updated) 18/06/2014 09:41
Font- Font+
A child, with hands chained, takes part in a protest calling for the
release of Palestinian prisoners from Israeli jails.(MaanImages/file)

BETHLEHEM (Ma'an) -- Israel gave initial approval this week for a law which would legalize the force feeding of Palestinian hunger strikers, drawing condemnation from human rights groups who say the bill is tantamount to torture.

The law, which is being pushed by Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Israel's health ministry, passed a first reading in the Knesset by a vote of 29 to 18 and would allow doctors to force feed Palestinian prisoners if their lives are in danger.

The bill is to be presented to the Knesset for final readings next week.

Since April 24, some 125 jailed Palestinians have been refusing meals in what Addameer prisoner rights group says is the longest collective hunger strike in Palestinian history.

According to the group, the proposed legislation is a clear attempt to break mass hunger strike action by Palestinian prisoners, which has over the past two years posed a constant challenge to Israel's detention policies.

"After almost two years of continuous hunger strikes, Israel feels that they have to deal with it in some way. They have tried everything else," Gavan Kelly, Addameer's international advocacy coordinator, told Ma'an.

Since 2011, not a single day has passed where a Palestinian prisoner has not been on hunger strike, Kelly says, leading the Israeli government to look for alternatives in dealing with collective protest action.

"The reality is that even though the Israeli government will say that they have the health of prisoners in mind, it is nonsense. Everyone is well aware that force-feeding limits the political damage of the hunger strikes."

In 2012, over 2,500 Palestinian prisoners went on hunger strike to protest prison conditions and administrative detention, eventually drawing concessions by Israel which were later reneged on.

Amany Dayif of Physicians for Human Rights-Israel says that the proposed new law is an attempt to limit any repercussions from the potential death of hunger strikers while simultaneously maintaining the policy of administrative detention.

"Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and the Shin Bet security agency are trying to resolve a political issue by using force, instead of resolving the issues raised by Palestinian prisoners which are Israel's detention policies," she told Ma'an.

Palestinians hold up photos of their imprisoned relatives at a support
rally in al-Bireh for over 100 hunger striking administrative detainees
on May 13, 2014 (MaanImages/Graham Liddell)

'No country in the world has legalized force-feeding'

The Association for Civil Rights in Israel said this week that they are deeply concerned by Netanyahu's intention to force-feed hunger striking prisoners who are being held in administrative detention, pointing to the underlying issue of Israel's detention policies against Palestinians.

"The hunger strike being carried out by prisoners held in administrative shines a light on one of the most severe injustices of military rule in the occupied territories," the group said.

"Palestinian residents are routinely held in administrative detention for many months, sometimes even years, without being informed of the charges against them or when they will be released."

Since 1967, thousands of Palestinians have been held under this policy, which allows the Israeli military to hold prisoners indefinitely on secret information without charging them or allowing them to stand trial.

The UN Secretary General Ban-ki Moon said last week that Israel must either charge or release Palestinian hunger strikers "without delay," while the UN high commissioner for human rights has also expressed concern regarding Israel's force feeding bill.

The practice of force feeding has been prohibited since 1975 based on the Declaration of Tokyo adopted by the World Medical Association, which provided guidelines for physicians in relation to detention and imprisonment.

The Israeli Medical Association last week condemned the practice as "torture," and urged physicians not to take part in the practice.

Despite this, Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu has said he will find physicians willing to undertake the procedure, and has even pointed to the use of force-feeding in Guantanamo Bay to justify the practice.

"There is no country in the world that has a law legalizing force feeding," Dayif told Ma'an. "The fear is that Israeli Prison Service doctors, and of course other individual doctors, would feel that if the law is permitting it then no harm would come to them if they implemented it."

The policy of force-feeding is a last stop measure by the Israeli government which will inevitably have unintended consequences unless the root issue of detention without trial is addressed, Dayif says.

"I don't think that force has ever proved to be the solution to any situation, but exactly the opposite. It (force-feeding) will mobilize the Palestinian street and Palestinian communities, together with other Arab prisoners in the Israeli prison services."

Sivan Weizman, spokeswoman for the Israeli Prison Service, told Ma'an that at the moment none of the hunger-strikers lives are in danger, noting that 75 prisoners are in hospital but there is no one in a "dangerous or critical condition."

There are currently 5,271 Palestinian prisoners in Israeli jails, including 192 administrative detainees, 17 women and 196 children, according to Addameer.
1 ) Rondo Mondo / Canada
11/06/2014 20:21
Doublespeak: "I don't think that force has ever proved to be the solution to any situation, but exactly the opposite." The use of and planning of force against Israelis, is exactly why Palestinians are in administrative detention. Someone should tell the Palestinians that force has never proved to be the solution to any solution. If Palestinians gave up the use of and threatening force, the requirement of administrative detention would disappear. The mistake the Palestinians make is ... contd

2 ) Rondo Mondo / Canada
11/06/2014 20:29
Part 2, The mistake Palestinians make is that they think they have the right to attack Israel and Israel has no right to defend itself from the harmful behavior of the Palestinians. 25,000 Israelis have been killed in the conflict. If Israel has to force feed prisoners to prevent further violence from the Palestinian side it will. The prisoners are using the threat of mass violence in case of their deaths if their wishes are not granted. Why should Israel give in to this blackmail?

3 ) Mel / USA
11/06/2014 20:30
Force-feeding is torture,plain & simple.But that's what Zionist-Israel is built on,the unforgiveable perpetuation of torture. Do unto other as WAS done to you,eh?& to he**with anti-Semitism,human rights &democracy! Is that why USG &Israel have such a 'special bond"....in SHAME! And remember this brave volunteer is STRONG &healthy! Not already near-starved.

4 ) Many iin Israel demand to / LET THEM DIE
12/06/2014 08:54
if that is THEIR WISH!!!!

5 ) HB / UK
12/06/2014 09:10
Rondo Mondo.... 25'000 Israeli's may have been killed, but you failed to mention that 90'000 Palestinians have been killed. If you are going to mention one statistic you should probably mention the other.

6 ) Scarlett / Palestine
12/06/2014 10:27
Rondo Mondo, I assume you believe that the world is round? So why have you not caught up with humanity yet regarding the possibility that an imprisoned nation, without arms, could be a security threat? Or are you suggesting that in Israel the world is not round? In which case I agree with you. Somehow, somewhere between Russia, America and the middle-east, facts lost their meaning. And a defensive and confused nation was born.

7 ) Rondo Mondo / Canada
12/06/2014 15:09
HB, I do not know where you get your stats from but there have not been 90,000 combined Israelis and Palestinians killed in the conflict. Maybe you are referring to total estimated Arab losses from Arab mercenaries to Arab country soldiers killed in 1948, 1956, 1967, 1973, 1982, and 2006 in wars with Israel. Arab numbers are always murky because of poor record keeping and propaganda in the Arab world.

8 ) Mel / USA
12/06/2014 17:00
Cont: Here are more stats for Rondo showing massively disproportionate death 'Statistics'(t among occupied Palestinians(especially children)& these also only cover certain periods.You can find stats in the JewishVirtualLibrary,involving Israeli deaths in Leb.Syr,Egy,Pal combined(lumping all 'Arabs' together).Hey Rondo,ask the IDF about Israeli fratricide & why suicide rates are higher in Israeli's,than death by Palestinian attacks? Wake up dude!

9 ) dominique / uk
12/06/2014 17:03
Israel is not a state it's a Nazi state ! Boycott Israelis production!

10 ) Rondo Mondo / Canada
12/06/2014 20:10
Mel - only 7 Israeli soldiers in 2013 and 14 in 2012 committed suicide. By comparison there were 474 suicides in the American forces in 2013 and 522 in 2012. Overall Israel's suicide rate for the whole country is half of the American rate. JVL proves my point. 90,000 Palestinians have not been killed. More Palestinians die than Israelis because Israeli protect their civilians by building shelters instead of strapping bombs on them or using them as human shields and cannon fodder.

11 ) Colin Wright / USA
25/06/2014 00:33
To Rondo Mondo #1: 'Doublespeak: "I don't think that force has ever proved to be the solution to any situation, but exactly the opposite." The use of and planning of force against Israelis, is exactly why Palestinians are in administrative detention...' It is your own words that constitute double-speak. The Palestinians are in 'administrative detention' precisely because Israel has nothing to charge them with.

12 ) Colin Wright / USA
25/06/2014 00:38
To Rondo Mondo #7: '.... Arab numbers are always murky because of poor record keeping and propaganda in the Arab world.' Then too, mass graves where Zionists murdered hundreds keep turning up. The corpses from 1948 found in Haifa, for example, or the P.O.W.'s the Israelis tied up and then shot in 1967. Just how many did the Zionists manage to get killed at Sabra and Chantila? It all serves to further obscure the totals, doesn't it?
Name Country
Note: Comments will be reviewed for appropriate content. Click here for more details.


Gaza's newly displaced cram into packed UN schools
Muslims mark somber Eid in bloodied Gaza
Documenting death: The man who counts the bodies in Gaza

Close Next Previous
All Rights Reserved © Ma'an News Agency 2005 - 2014